Note: Gilman players were in the light pants.
From the 1956-1957 Cynosure: "Gilman held the edge in victories, twenty-three to seventeen, as the teams took the field and prepared to square off. Early in the first period, Tom Bowyer recovered a Farmer fumble, and Riggs scored six plays later. Riggs scored twice more, and Brian, Garrett, and Barker, G. each scored once before McDonogh could gather any momentum. Everybody played, and everybody had a good time as Gilman gained the victory by a score of 39-14."